It's water-based so it's safe for use with condoms and sex toys too. It might not look like much, but this lubricant actually has some of the highest rated reviews on Amazon. What makes a lube great for anal play might not make it great for toy usage, and it might be worth investing in specific lubes for specific sex acts. Add a drop of water or spit during use to "reactivate" the lube if it starts to dry out. Yup, you can use regs coconut oil for lube! Because it can solidify in cold weather, you'll have to heat it up in your hands before you get things going—something to take into consideration especially in these colder months. Organic Extra Virgin Coconut Oil. This oil-based lube is made with coconut oil and organic silicone, which according to the company, are the same ingredients commonly used as de-tangler in hair conditioner. Here are our top picks for the best anal lubricants:.